A California law set to impose restrictions on licensed gun holders from carrying firearms in various public places has faced a setback, as a federal judge declared it unconstitutional. The law in question, Senate Bill 2, signed by Governor Gavin Newsom on September 26, encompasses several gun control measures. However, one of its regulations, specifically the prohibition on licensed gun carrying in public places, has been halted by U.S. District Judge Cormac J. Carney.
The order, issued on December 20, prevents the full implementation of SB 2, which aimed to make it illegal for licensed gun carriers in California to carry firearms in locations such as bars, churches, parks, public events, stadiums, casinos, financial institutions, medical facilities, on public transportation, and more.
Judge Carney, in his ruling, underscored the Second Amendment’s preservation of a fundamental constitutional right for law-abiding citizens to keep and bear arms for self-defense. He noted the contemporary need for individuals to carry handguns in public for personal safety in a society characterized by the ubiquity of guns and high levels of gun violence.
Acknowledging the responsible nature of those legally carrying guns, Carney emphasized that holders of concealed carry permits (CCW) undergo a rigorous vetting and training process. Contrary to the intent behind SB 2, Carney stated that CCW permitholders are not responsible for mass shootings or widespread gun violence in California.
Moreover, the judge argued that SB 2 could expose law-abiding citizens to potential harm by restricting their ability to protect themselves. He asserted that the provisions of the law would unconstitutionally deprive certain individuals, particularly those living in high-crime neighborhoods, of their constitutional right to carry a handgun in public for self-defense.
As a result of these concerns, Judge Carney concluded that the relevant provisions of SB 2 must be preliminarily enjoined, emphasizing the potential infringement on the constitutional rights of law-abiding citizens.