The U.S. Department of Justice has concluded that the Worcester Police Department (WPD) engaged in a pattern of civil rights violations, including excessive use of force and allowing undercover officers to engage in inappropriate sexual conduct with women involved in the commercial sex trade. These findings, released on Monday by the Justice Department’s Civil Rights Division, followed an extensive two-year investigation into potential systemic misconduct by the department.
The report reveals that Worcester police have repeatedly violated individuals’ constitutional rights, causing significant harm to the community. Specifically, the investigation highlighted troubling practices where undercover officers coerced or misled women suspected of engaging in sex work into providing sex acts. A 2019 survey by a local advocacy group found that over half of women surveyed reported being manipulated into sex acts by police officers. This pattern of abuse was a key focus of the Justice Department’s investigation.
The investigation, which was prompted by concerns raised by local advocacy groups as early as 2019, paints a disturbing picture of misconduct within the Worcester Police Department. It details instances where officers, while acting undercover, used their authority to exploit vulnerable women for sexual acts, under the guise of law enforcement operations aimed at curbing sex trafficking.
The report also touched on the department’s response to public protests following the 2020 killing of George Floyd by police officers in Minneapolis. Worcester residents, rallying against police brutality, faced an aggressive police response, with officers outfitted in riot gear, which further exacerbated tensions between the community and law enforcement.
The investigation represents one of the 12 civil rights probes launched by the Biden administration into police departments accused of systemic abuses. These investigations have come in stark contrast to the previous administration’s lack of such inquiries during President Donald Trump’s term.
Worcester’s outside counsel, Brian Kelly, issued a statement in defense of the police department, calling the Justice Department’s report “unfair, inaccurate, and biased.” Kelly challenged the report’s findings, asking why no individual officers had been prosecuted and why the Justice Department had only issued a report rather than taking formal action against the department.
“Anyone reviewing this report should ask themselves: if the allegations in this report are true, why hasn’t the DOJ prosecuted a single officer and simply drafted a report by DOJ’s Civil Rights Division?” Kelly said in the statement.
While the Worcester Police Department has made some efforts to address these concerns, such as implementing body-worn cameras and establishing a policy review committee, the Justice Department emphasized that these reforms are insufficient. The report stresses that the WPD must take more substantial actions to repair its relationship with the community and address the widespread civil rights violations uncovered in the investigation.
The Department of Justice also indicated that it would be seeking feedback from Worcester residents regarding potential remedies to resolve the issues raised in the report. Despite the acknowledgment of some progress, the report made clear that further action was necessary to bring about meaningful change.
The Biden administration’s Justice Department has yet to formalize any consent decrees with cities found to have systemic police misconduct, which legal experts say may present challenges in ensuring lasting reforms.
The findings come at a time of heightened scrutiny on police practices, as the Biden administration continues to confront systemic abuses within law enforcement agencies across the country. Legal experts predict that with the upcoming change in administration, investigations into police misconduct may shift in focus.
As the city of Worcester grapples with these findings, both local and national attention will likely be on how the WPD responds to the report’s call for further reform.
Read more: