In a significant legal move that could reshape the landscape of automotive technology, California-based Tekion has filed a lawsuit against its larger competitor, CDK Global, alleging monopolistic practices in the dealership management systems market. The lawsuit was lodged on Monday in federal court in San Francisco and accuses CDK of employing illegal tactics to maintain its dominance, ultimately harming dealers and consumers alike.
Tekion’s complaint highlights how CDK has allegedly obstructed dealers’ efforts to transition to alternative management platforms. This obstruction has reportedly resulted in inflated costs for dealerships that rely heavily on these systems to manage their daily operations, including inventory tracking, sales management, customer relations, and service coordination.
According to Tekion’s founder and CEO, Jay Vijayan, the company is committed to promoting fairness and competition within the automotive retail ecosystem. In a statement released on Tuesday, Vijayan remarked, “We have decided to stand up to CDK’s illegal practices to preserve fairness and competition in the automotive retail ecosystem.” This declaration underscores Tekion’s determination to challenge what it perceives as anti-competitive behavior by CDK.
The lawsuit specifically alleges that CDK has violated antitrust laws by withholding or delaying access to critical operational data that dealers need to switch providers. This tactic not only complicates the transition process but also keeps dealers tethered to CDK’s systems, thereby limiting their options and inflating prices.
The ongoing conflict between Tekion and CDK escalated earlier this year when a major franchise dealership opted to partner with Tekion for a pilot program. In a related ruling, a Georgia judge ordered CDK to provide Tekion with essential data necessary for conducting a pilot involving four dealerships under Asbury Automotive Group, which operates 158 dealerships across 15 states.
The ramifications of CDK’s alleged practices have been significant for Tekion, which claims it has suffered economic harm due to loss of revenue, market share erosion, and increased operational costs. The lawsuit seeks unspecified monetary damages and an injunction requiring CDK to deliver dealer data within a specified timeframe.
This legal battle is not an isolated incident for CDK Global. The company is currently facing multiple antitrust claims. Notably, a U.S. judge recently ruled that software vendors developing applications for dealer management systems could pursue class-action lawsuits against CDK for allegedly restricting data access and imposing excessive charges on dealers.
In August, CDK announced it would pay $100 million to settle a nationwide class action lawsuit brought by retail auto dealerships claiming they had been overcharged for the company’s dealer management systems. While CDK did not admit wrongdoing in this settlement, the ongoing scrutiny suggests a growing concern over its business practices.
As this case unfolds in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California (Case No. 3:24-cv-08879), industry stakeholders will be watching closely. The outcome could have profound implications for competition within the automotive technology sector and may lead to increased scrutiny of how major players operate in this vital industry.
Read more: