Malaysia’s leading palm oil lobby group has praised the European Union’s recent decision to postpone the implementation of a stringent deforestation law, which it argued threatened the economic sustainability of the palm oil industry. The Malaysian Palm Oil Council (MPOC) lauded the move as a “victory for common sense,” viewing it as a much-needed reprieve for small farmers who rely on the commodity.
The European Union Deforestation Regulation (EUDR) seeks to prevent products that contribute to global deforestation from entering its markets. The regulation aims to block the import of seven key commodities, including coffee, cocoa, soy, beef, rubber, wood, and palm oil, if they are sourced from deforested areas. To comply, exporters must provide documentation tracing these products back to their original plots of land, using satellite data and mapping tools.
Initially set to take effect on December 30, 2024, the EUDR implementation has been delayed by a year, with the European Commission announcing the new enforcement date as 2025.
Malaysia and Indonesia Raise Concerns
Malaysia and Indonesia, the world’s largest palm oil producers, have been vocal opponents of the regulation. Both countries argued that the original 2024 deadline was unrealistic and placed undue pressure on smallholders who might struggle to meet the new standards.
The MPOC, responsible for promoting Malaysia’s palm oil industry—used in a wide range of products from food to cosmetics—welcomed the delay. “This is a sensible and much-needed step, providing relief to businesses needing additional time to comply with the EUDR’s complex regulatory demands,” said Belvinder Sron, the Council’s CEO, in a statement.
For Malaysia, the European Union is a crucial trading partner, ranking as the third-largest export destination for palm oil, behind India and China. However, the industry has long been linked to environmental concerns, with vast swaths of Malaysia’s rainforests being cleared for palm oil plantations. Between 2000 and 2012, more than 12 million acres of rainforest were converted into plantations, leading to significant habitat loss for endangered species like the Malayan tiger and orangutans.
Impact on Smallholders and Global Supply Chains
The deferral of the EUDR, according to Sron, allows the global supply chains to adapt to the regulation’s technical and administrative requirements without causing trade disruptions. This is especially important for smallholder farmers who produce a significant portion of Malaysia’s palm oil.
A 2020 report by Serina Rahman, a conservation scientist at Singapore’s ISEAS Yusof Ishak Institute, highlighted the critical role of smallholders in Malaysia’s palm oil sector. According to the report, 40% of Malaysia’s palm oil output is produced by smallholders, many of whom operate under poor social and environmental standards due to financial constraints. The study found that 13% of these smallholders are family-run businesses that struggle to meet higher standards because of low income, averaging just 1,600 ringgit (US$377) per month. This is significantly below Malaysia’s poverty line of 2,208 ringgit (US$521).
Political Response to the EUDR
Malaysia’s concerns over the EUDR were raised at the highest levels of government. Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim addressed the issue during a meeting with German President Frank-Walter Steinmeier in February, where he expressed frustration over the EU’s rigidity. Anwar urged the EU to consider the economic challenges faced by the region, pointing to Malaysia’s reforestation efforts as evidence of its commitment to sustainable practices. “We have taken all the necessary measures, including reforestation, but they should allow us to function economically,” Anwar said, stressing the need for a more flexible approach.
Malaysia’s Plantation and Commodities Minister, Fadillah Yusof, has also been outspoken against the EUDR, particularly its impact on smallholders. He argued that the regulations would exacerbate poverty in rural areas, calling the rules “a significant stumbling block.” Yusof warned that the strict regulations are inconsistent with the EU’s commitments under the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals, adding that the regulations could harm communities that rely on palm oil production for their livelihoods.
In March 2023, more than 500 smallholders from Malaysia signed a petition urging the EU to reconsider the EUDR, describing it as discriminatory. Many smallholders feel overlooked by the new regulations, with some arguing that they are being unfairly penalized for practices largely driven by demand from international markets.
Indigenous Communities and the MSPO Certification
The Dayak Oil Palm Planters Association (DOPPA), which represents indigenous Dayak communities in Sarawak, also criticized the EU’s lack of understanding of Malaysia’s palm oil supply chain. The association has called on the EU to accept the existing Malaysian Sustainable Palm Oil (MSPO) certification as an alternative compliance standard. The MSPO, they argue, is inclusive and addresses key concerns raised by the EU, such as deforestation, child labor, and forced labor.
The MSPO certification, which includes rigorous standards for deforestation prevention, mandatory reporting, and third-party auditing, has been recognized as a robust framework by experts. A June 2023 report by the European Forest Institute described the MSPO as a “world-class standard for agriculture.”
While the delay in the implementation of the EUDR offers temporary relief, Malaysia and its palm oil industry remain at the center of an ongoing global debate over sustainability, trade, and environmental responsibility. The postponement provides time for the industry to adapt, but the challenge of balancing economic interests with environmental commitments persists.
Related Topics: