Military pensions are often one of the largest assets in a military divorce. Dividing these pensions is a complex process, involving federal and state laws, as well as specific rules related to military benefits. Understanding how military pensions are divided during divorce requires careful navigation of the Uniformed Services Former Spouses’ Protection Act (USFSPA) and other legal frameworks. This article provides a comprehensive guide on how to divide military pensions during divorce, including the key factors, legal considerations, and the steps involved.
Understanding Military Pensions and Divorce
Military pensions are a significant asset in many divorces involving military personnel. The process of dividing these pensions during divorce differs from civilian pensions due to the unique rules and regulations surrounding military benefits. Understanding the basics of military pensions and how they are classified is the first step in navigating this issue.
What is a Military Pension?
A military pension is a retirement benefit provided to service members who have served for at least 20 years in the United States Armed Forces. It is calculated based on the length of service and the pay grade of the service member at retirement. Military pensions are considered a form of deferred compensation, meaning they are earned during the marriage but paid out after the service member retires.
Military pensions are generally paid out monthly to the retired service member and can constitute a substantial portion of the couple’s marital assets, especially in long-term marriages. These pensions are not automatically divided upon divorce but are subject to division under state laws, in accordance with federal regulations.
The Uniformed Services Former Spouses’ Protection Act (USFSPA)
The USFSPA is a federal law that governs how military pensions can be divided in divorce. Enacted in 1982, the USFSPA allows state courts to treat military pensions as marital property, subject to division in divorce proceedings. The act does not create an automatic entitlement for the non-military spouse but rather gives state courts the discretion to divide the pension based on state divorce laws.
Key provisions of the USFSPA include:
Allowing state courts to divide military retirement pay as part of the marital estate.
Limiting the amount of retirement pay that can be awarded to a former spouse.
Requiring certain conditions for direct payment from the Defense Finance and Accounting Service (DFAS).
See also: How to Divide Assets Without a Lawyer？
Factors Influencing the Division of Military Pensions
The division of military pensions in a divorce is influenced by several factors, including the length of the marriage, the overlap between marriage and military service, and state-specific laws. Understanding these factors is crucial for both the service member and the spouse.
The 10/10 Rule
One of the key factors affecting the division of military pensions is the “10/10 rule.” Under this rule, the former spouse can receive direct payments from the DFAS only if the couple was married for at least 10 years, during which the service member completed at least 10 years of creditable military service.
This rule does not affect whether the pension is divisible; it only governs whether the DFAS can make direct payments to the former spouse. If the couple does not meet the 10/10 rule, the former spouse may still be entitled to a portion of the pension, but the service member will be responsible for making payments directly to the spouse.
Marital Property vs. Separate Property
In most states, military pensions are considered marital property, meaning they are subject to division between spouses during divorce. However, the portion of the pension earned before the marriage or after the divorce is generally considered separate property and is not subject to division.
For example, if a service member was in the military for 25 years but was married for only 15 of those years, the pension will likely be divided based on the years of service that occurred during the marriage. This is known as the “coverture fraction,” which calculates the marital share of the pension.
Division Methods for Military Pensions
There are several methods for dividing military pensions during divorce, each with its own advantages and disadvantages. The choice of method will depend on the circumstances of the divorce, the preferences of the parties, and state laws.
Present Value Offset Method
The present value offset method involves calculating the current value of the military pension and offsetting it against other marital assets. In this approach, the service member keeps the entire pension, but the former spouse receives other assets of equal value. This method is often preferred when both parties want to avoid ongoing financial ties, but it requires accurate valuation of the pension and other assets.
Advantages: This method allows for a clean break between the parties, as the former spouse receives a lump sum or equivalent assets instead of monthly payments.
Disadvantages: It can be difficult to accurately calculate the present value of the pension, and the service member must have sufficient other assets to offset the value of the pension.
Deferred Distribution Method
The deferred distribution method involves dividing the pension payments once the service member begins receiving them in retirement. The former spouse receives a percentage of each monthly payment, based on the portion of the pension earned during the marriage. This method is commonly used when the service member has not yet retired or when the parties prefer ongoing financial support.
Advantages: This method is straightforward and does not require complex calculations. It ensures the former spouse receives a portion of the pension as it is paid out.
Disadvantages: The former spouse must wait until the service member retires to begin receiving payments, and the service member may reduce the pension by taking early retirement or selecting certain benefit options.
Legal Considerations and Court Orders
Dividing military pensions during divorce involves both federal and state laws, as well as specific court orders. Ensuring that the correct legal procedures are followed is essential for both parties to protect their rights.
Qualifying Court Order
To divide a military pension, the court must issue a Qualified Domestic Relations Order (QDRO) or, in the case of military pensions, a Military Retired Pay Division Order. This order instructs the DFAS to divide the pension and make direct payments to the former spouse. The order must meet specific requirements under the USFSPA and state law to be enforceable.
Survivor Benefit Plan (SBP)
In addition to dividing the pension itself, divorcing spouses must also consider the Survivor Benefit Plan (SBP). The SBP allows the former spouse to continue receiving a portion of the military pension if the service member dies after retirement. Without the SBP, the pension payments stop upon the service member’s death.
The SBP can be awarded to a former spouse as part of the divorce settlement, but it must be clearly stated in the court order. The cost of the SBP is typically deducted from the pension payments, so the parties must decide how to handle the cost of this benefit.
Challenges and Pitfalls in Dividing Military Pensions
Dividing military pensions during divorce can be complicated, and there are several challenges and pitfalls that both parties should be aware of.
Misunderstanding the 10/10 Rule
One common misunderstanding is the belief that the 10/10 rule determines whether the pension is divisible. In reality, this rule only governs direct payments from the DFAS. A former spouse may still be entitled to a portion of the pension, even if the couple was married for less than 10 years during military service.
Failure to Properly Value the Pension
Another challenge is accurately valuing the military pension. Because military pensions are paid out over time, determining their present value can be complex. In some cases, parties may underestimate or overestimate the value of the pension, leading to an unfair division of assets. Hiring a financial expert or actuary may be necessary to properly value the pension.
Overlooking Survivor Benefits
Failing to address the Survivor Benefit Plan (SBP) is another common pitfall. If the SBP is not awarded to the former spouse in the divorce settlement, the pension payments will stop if the service member dies, leaving the former spouse without financial support. It is crucial to include provisions for the SBP in the divorce order if the former spouse is to receive continued benefits.
Working with Legal and Financial Experts
Dividing military pensions during divorce often requires the assistance of legal and financial experts. An experienced divorce attorney with knowledge of military pension division is essential for ensuring that the process is handled correctly.
Role of Divorce Attorneys
Divorce attorneys play a critical role in negotiating the division of military pensions and drafting the necessary court orders. They can help ensure that the division complies with both federal and state laws and that the former spouse receives the benefits they are entitled to. Attorneys can also advise on the best division method and how to handle survivor benefits.
Role of Financial Advisors and Actuaries
Financial advisors and actuaries can assist in valuing the military pension and calculating the marital portion. They can also provide advice on how to offset the pension against other assets or how to structure the division to meet the financial needs of both parties. In complex cases, expert financial guidance is essential for ensuring a fair division.
Conclusion
Dividing military pensions during divorce is a complex process that involves navigating federal laws like the USFSPA, state divorce laws, and specific rules regarding military benefits. It requires careful consideration of factors such as the length of the marriage, the 10/10 rule, and the method of division. By understanding these elements and working with experienced legal and financial professionals, divorcing spouses can ensure a fair and equitable division of military pensions. Proper planning and attention to legal details, such as survivor benefits and court orders, are essential for protecting the financial future of both parties.
Related articles:
How to Divide Assets in a Divorce UK: A Comprehensive Guide
What Is The ‘Rule Of 65’ In California Divorce ?
What Assets Are Untouchable During Divorce?