Former President Donald Trump’s ongoing legal challenges may soon be decided by the U.S. Supreme Court, but whether those cases ever reach the high court could hinge on the results of the upcoming November election.
As the election season heats up, Trump faces a host of legal battles, some of which could directly impact his future political career. Currently, there are seven key cases involving Trump pending in lower courts, spanning both criminal and civil charges. These cases could eventually be appealed to the Supreme Court, but whether they will be depends largely on the results of the 2024 U.S. presidential election.
Trump, who is running as the Republican candidate, is facing off against Democratic Vice President Kamala Harris. The outcome of this race will not only determine the next President but could also influence the trajectory of Trump’s legal entanglements. If he wins, the political landscape would shift dramatically, with Trump potentially seeking to pardon himself or have his newly appointed Justice Department drop charges, especially in federal cases overseen by Special Counsel Jack Smith.
Currently, Trump is dealing with two major federal criminal cases: one related to his alleged efforts to overturn the 2020 election and another concerning the mishandling of classified documents. A win in November would give him significant power to alter the course of these cases, potentially halting the investigations entirely.
However, state-level cases, including the hush-money payment case in New York and the election interference charges in Georgia, are beyond the reach of a presidential pardon. These cases would continue regardless of Trump’s success in the presidential race.
In addition to criminal charges, Trump faces several civil lawsuits, including a case in New York regarding civil fraud charges linked to his business practices, as well as two lawsuits from E. Jean Carroll, who has accused him of sexual assault and defamation. Trump is actively appealing these cases, and the outcome could eventually make its way to the Supreme Court as well.
In recent months, the Supreme Court has delivered favorable rulings for Trump. The justices granted him a significant victory in a case concerning presidential immunity, ruling that former presidents are largely protected from criminal prosecution for actions taken within their official duties. This decision could prove pivotal as Trump’s team continues to argue that many of the charges against him fall under this immunity.
However, legal experts agree that much remains uncertain. If Trump loses the election, the cases would likely continue to move through the lower courts, with the Supreme Court ultimately making critical decisions on issues like immunity and the legitimacy of the special counsel’s appointment.
Georgetown Law professor Erica Hashimoto suggests that should Trump lose, the Supreme Court will likely be called upon to clarify the scope of its earlier ruling, particularly in the case concerning Smith’s appointment. “If the election goes against Trump, the Court will likely revisit these issues,” she said.
A second term in office could radically change the landscape of Trump’s legal cases. As president, he would have the authority to dismiss federal charges by removing Special Counsel Jack Smith or using his power to pardon himself, something Trump’s allies have openly discussed. However, this won’t extend to state charges, which will likely persist regardless of who sits in the Oval Office.
Moreover, Trump’s strong conservative appointments to the Supreme Court—including Justices Amy Coney Barrett, Brett Kavanaugh, and Neil Gorsuch—could play a decisive role in future rulings regarding the president’s immunity and the broader interpretation of constitutional law as it pertains to his cases.
The coming months could see significant developments as Trump’s cases progress through the courts and his election campaign intensifies. Legal experts and political observers agree that the outcome of the November election will have a profound impact on the direction of his legal battles—and whether they will ultimately be resolved by the U.S. Supreme Court.
The final decision could set critical legal precedents for the relationship between the presidency, the courts, and the accountability of public officials, impacting not only Trump but future presidents as well.
Read more:
NLRB Judge Upholds NTT Data’S Noncompete Agreement, Breaks From Previous Ruling
Federal Lawsuit Targets Virginia’s Voter Registration Practices Before November Polls
Litigation Funder Files Legal Challenge To NJ Law Keeping Judges’ Information Hidden