The U.S. Supreme Court convened on Tuesday to deliberate a pivotal case that could reshape the landscape of wage law and employer obligations under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). The justices examined whether employers should face a higher evidentiary standard when proving that their employees qualify for exemptions from overtime pay and other protections.
The case, E.M.D. Sales Inc. v. Carrera, stems from a ruling by the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which mandated that EMD Sales demonstrate its sales representatives were ineligible for overtime pay by “clear and convincing evidence.” This standard is notably more stringent than the “preponderance of the evidence” standard applied by six other circuit courts.
During the hour-long arguments, attorney Lauren Bateman represented the sales representatives, asserting that FLSA protections are crucial not only for individual rights but also for maintaining fair competition among businesses. She argued that a higher burden of proof is warranted due to the significant implications of misclassification in wage disputes.
However, Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Samuel Alito challenged Bateman’s position, questioning why such a heightened standard should apply uniquely to the FLSA when other laws with public interest implications do not require it. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson appeared more receptive to Bateman’s arguments, suggesting that the interests at stake extend beyond mere monetary damages.
The Supreme Court’s decision to review this case comes at a time when FLSA exemptions are under increased scrutiny, especially as businesses navigate complex wage and hour regulations. A ruling favoring the lower standard could alleviate compliance burdens for employers, particularly in states governed by the 4th Circuit’s stricter requirements.
The outcome of this case is anticipated to have far-reaching effects on how employers classify employees and manage overtime compensation claims. The Supreme Court is expected to issue its ruling by the end of its term in 2025.
Read more: