The U.S. Supreme Court is deliberating on Facebook’s bid to dismiss a securities fraud lawsuit filed by shareholders who accuse the social media giant of misleading investors about data misuse. The case, led by Amalgamated Bank, challenges whether Facebook’s failure to disclose a significant 2015 data breach, involving the British consultancy Cambridge Analytica, constituted a violation of securities law.
Central to the case is the interpretation of risk disclosures, which companies are legally required to provide to alert investors to potential business threats. The lawsuit argues that Facebook’s disclosure statements misled investors by framing the risk of data misuse as a future possibility, despite the 2015 breach affecting over 30 million users. After the Cambridge Analytica scandal surfaced in 2018, Facebook’s stock took a significant hit, costing shareholders substantial losses and prompting government investigations and fines.
During Wednesday’s hearing, the Court’s conservative justices appeared divided. Chief Justice John Roberts noted that a reasonable investor might interpret Facebook’s forward-looking statements as acknowledging past risks, while Justice Clarence Thomas questioned whether the lack of clarity in the statements could lead investors to believe such events hadn’t occurred.
Justice Elena Kagan emphasized that misleading omissions could be grounds for liability, while Justices Brett Kavanaugh and Neil Gorsuch inquired if other regulatory disclosures could address past incidents like the Cambridge Analytica breach. Facebook’s attorney, Kannon Shanmugam, argued that their risk disclosures were future-oriented, consistent with regulatory standards, and not misleading.
President Joe Biden’s administration has voiced support for the shareholders. A ruling from the Supreme Court, expected by June, could significantly impact the standards for corporate transparency and investor protection in securities law.
The outcome of this case, along with a similar one involving Nvidia later this month, has the potential to shape the accountability of corporations in securities fraud cases, setting new benchmarks for risk disclosure.
Read more: