Sotheby’s, the renowned auction house, has reached a significant settlement with the State of New York, agreeing to pay $6.25 million to resolve allegations of tax fraud. This lawsuit, brought forth by New York Attorney General Letitia James, accused Sotheby’s of facilitating tax evasion for its clients by allowing them to falsely claim they were purchasing art for resale, thereby avoiding sales taxes on millions of dollars in art transactions.
The settlement, announced on Thursday, addresses claims that between 2010 and 2020, Sotheby’s assisted at least eight clients in circumventing New York’s sales tax laws. The auction house allegedly accepted “resale certificates” from these clients, misrepresenting them as art dealers entitled to tax exemptions rather than as private collectors. One notable client, identified only as “the Collector,” reportedly purchased over $27 million worth of artwork from renowned artists such as Jean-Michel Basquiat and Anish Kapoor while using these fraudulent certificates.
Attorney General James stated, “Sotheby’s intentionally broke the law. Every person and company in New York knows they are required to pay taxes, and when people break the rules, we all lose out.” The settlement amount includes damages, penalties, and legal costs incurred during the investigation.
While Sotheby’s did not admit to any wrongdoing in this case, they opted to settle to avoid the prolonged costs and distractions associated with litigation. In addition to the financial penalties, Sotheby’s has committed to implementing reforms aimed at ensuring compliance with New York tax laws. This includes establishing a new policy regarding resale certificates and enhancing employee training to better assess whether art buyers intend to resell their purchases.
The lawsuit was initially filed in November 2020 under the state’s False Claims Act, seeking damages and civil penalties for the alleged violations. The auction house’s actions not only raised questions about its business practices but also highlighted broader issues related to tax compliance within the art market.
This case is not an isolated incident; it follows a previous settlement involving Porsal Equities, linked to “the Collector,” which resulted in a $10.75 million payment to resolve similar claims regarding the misuse of resale certificates. Attorney General James noted that her office is committed to tackling tax evasion and ensuring that all entities adhere to state tax obligations.
Sotheby’s has publicly stated its commitment to full compliance with applicable laws and emphasized that it provided much of the evidence that led to the earlier Porsal settlement. As part of their ongoing efforts to maintain integrity in their operations, Sotheby’s will work closely with state authorities moving forward.
This settlement serves as a reminder of the importance of transparency and accountability in high-value transactions within the art world. As the market continues to evolve, stakeholders must remain vigilant against practices that undermine fair taxation and compliance with state laws.
Read more: