In the United States, political control of state governments is divided among the two major political parties: the Democratic Party and the Republican Party. State control is crucial, as it impacts the development and enforcement of laws on a wide array of issues, including healthcare, education, criminal justice, and voting rights. This article explores the current political landscape in U.S. states, focusing on how many are under Democratic control, the significance of this control, and the shifting dynamics that influence the power balance at the state level.
Understanding Democratic Control in State Governments
What Does Democratic Control Mean?
In American politics, a state is considered “Democratically controlled” if the Democratic Party holds the majority of seats in both the state legislature (the Senate and the House of Representatives, or Assembly) and the governor’s office. This gives the party significant influence over the state’s legislative agenda, budget, and policy decisions.
Control is typically defined by the party affiliation of the governor and the majority party in both chambers of the state legislature. If the governor is a Democrat and both the state House and Senate are controlled by Democrats, the state is fully under Democratic control. Conversely, if the governor is a Democrat but one or both legislative chambers are controlled by Republicans, the state may be classified as “divided” or “split.”
It’s important to note that political control at the state level can vary from one election cycle to the next, as gubernatorial races and legislative elections occur regularly. Consequently, the political makeup of state governments can shift over time in response to changes in voter preferences, national political trends, and issues that dominate public discourse.
Historical Context of State Control
Historically, the balance of power in state governments has fluctuated between the two major parties. Since the early 21st century, however, the political landscape has become increasingly polarized, leading to a more pronounced division of control between the states. In the 2010s, the Republican Party gained significant ground in state legislatures, largely due to successful gerrymandering efforts following the 2010 census. Conversely, Democrats have made strides in recent years, particularly in gubernatorial races and legislative chambers.
Current Political Landscape: States Under Democratic Control
The Number of States Currently Governed by Democrats
As of the most recent political cycles, the number of states under Democratic control can fluctuate, but there are key patterns to note. As of 2024, 17 states are considered to be fully controlled by the Democratic Party. These states have a Democratic governor, and both chambers of their state legislature are also controlled by the Democratic Party. This number can shift due to midterm elections or special elections, but the trend of Democratic control can be tied to both regional demographics and national political shifts.
States with Democratic Governors
In addition to the 17 states that are fully controlled by Democrats, there are several states where the governorship is held by a Democrat but the legislature is split or controlled by Republicans. While the governor in these states has significant influence, legislative gridlock is often the result, as a Republican-controlled legislature may resist policies proposed by a Democratic governor.
Examples of such states include Kentucky, Louisiana, and North Carolina, where a Democratic governor faces opposition from Republican majorities in the state legislature. These “divided” states show the challenges Democratic governors face in advancing their agendas without control over both legislative chambers.
Key States with Democratic Control
Some of the key states with full Democratic control include:
- California: The most populous state in the U.S. and a Democratic stronghold, with a Democratic governor and a supermajority in both chambers of the state legislature.
- New York: Another major state with a Democrat in the governor’s office, along with Democratic control of the state Assembly and Senate.
- Illinois: Known for its strong Democratic Party presence, Illinois has been fully controlled by Democrats for several years.
- Oregon: A consistently liberal state with Democrats in charge of both legislative chambers and the governor’s office.
- Colorado: A state that has shifted toward the Democratic Party in recent years, with both the governorship and legislature under Democratic control.
These states represent a mix of geographic regions, including both coastal liberal strongholds and states in the interior, illustrating the national scope of Democratic control.
Factors Influencing Democratic Control at the State Level
Demographic Shifts and Urbanization
One of the most significant factors contributing to Democratic control in many states is demographic change, particularly urbanization. Democratic strongholds tend to be located in large urban areas, where younger, more diverse populations are more likely to support progressive policies. As urban populations grow and suburban areas become more politically diverse, more states are trending Democratic.
For example, states like Georgia, Texas, and Arizona have seen rapid demographic changes, including increases in the Hispanic population and younger, more liberal voters. As these populations grow, they have contributed to shifts in political power, though these states remain competitive battlegrounds.
National Trends and Party Realignment
The political dynamics of the national political climate also play a critical role in determining which party controls state governments. For instance, national events like presidential elections, the state of the economy, and major social movements can influence state elections, particularly gubernatorial and legislative races.
In the 2018 and 2020 election cycles, the Democratic Party made significant gains in state legislatures, benefiting from dissatisfaction with Republican leadership in Washington and the Trump administration. In contrast, in 2014 and 2016, Republicans were able to secure a larger share of state governments, capitalizing on their successes at the national level.
Redistricting and Gerrymandering
Redistricting is another important factor influencing Democratic control. Every ten years, following the U.S. Census, states redraw their legislative districts, a process that can heavily influence political control. While both parties engage in gerrymandering, the Republican Party has had considerable success in manipulating district lines to secure legislative majorities in swing states like North Carolina and Ohio.
However, Democratic-controlled states have also engaged in gerrymandering to protect their majorities, particularly in states like Maryland and New Jersey, where district lines are drawn to benefit the Democratic Party.
Impacts of Democratic Control at the State Level
Policy Implementation and Legislative Agendas
States that are under full Democratic control typically pursue policies aligned with the party’s national platform, focusing on issues such as healthcare reform, environmental protections, education funding, criminal justice reform, and labor rights. Democratic-controlled states are more likely to expand access to healthcare through Medicaid, raise the minimum wage, and pass progressive laws on issues like reproductive rights and gun control.
For example, California’s Democratic legislature has passed sweeping climate change laws, while New York has implemented measures to protect reproductive rights and expand healthcare access. These policies reflect the values of the Democratic Party, which tends to favor more government intervention in areas like healthcare, education, and social justice.
Challenges to Policy Implementation
While Democratic control gives a state the ability to push through policies that align with the party’s values, it also presents challenges. Republican-controlled legislatures in some states can obstruct Democratic policy proposals, particularly in areas like tax policy, gun rights, and immigration. Additionally, divided governments, where the legislature is controlled by one party and the governor by another, can result in political gridlock, preventing significant legislative progress.
Conclusion
As of 2024, 17 states are fully under Democratic control, with a Democratic governor and a Democratic-majority legislature. This number may fluctuate in response to electoral changes, shifting demographics, and the political climate at both the state and national levels. The ability of the Democratic Party to maintain or expand control will depend on various factors, including voter turnout, demographic shifts, and the outcomes of key races in competitive states. Ultimately, the political control of states is a dynamic and evolving aspect of U.S. governance, one that will continue to shape policy decisions for years to come.
Related topics: