In a significant move, the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has launched an expansive antitrust investigation into Microsoft’s business practices, particularly focusing on its software licensing strategies and cloud computing operations. The investigation, which includes scrutiny of Microsoft’s Azure cloud service, is set to explore whether the tech giant has been abusing its market power to stifle competition.
This inquiry comes at a pivotal time, as the current FTC Chair, Lina Khan, is expected to step down in January. The investigation’s future direction may be influenced by the expected shift in regulatory approach following the anticipated appointment of a new Republican chair under a potential Trump administration. These developments have left the outcome of the investigation uncertain.
The FTC’s investigation is particularly concerned with Microsoft’s alleged use of punitive licensing terms to prevent customers from migrating their data from its Azure cloud service to other competitive platforms. This has raised alarms among competitors who argue that Microsoft’s practices may be locking customers into its ecosystem, effectively stifling competition in the cloud computing space.
In addition to its focus on cloud services, the FTC is also examining Microsoft’s practices related to its cybersecurity and artificial intelligence (AI) products. These practices, including the integration of AI tools into Microsoft’s Office and Outlook software, have raised concerns from competitors such as Amazon and Google, who are challenging the company’s tactics in both the cloud and AI markets.
Microsoft’s licensing policies have come under heavy fire from industry rivals and lobby groups. NetChoice, a trade association representing companies like Amazon and Google, has criticized Microsoft for using its market dominance to impose restrictions that make it difficult for customers to switch to alternative cloud providers. These practices are seen as a potential barrier to entry for competitors and a means of unfairly maintaining Microsoft’s cloud market share.
“Given that Microsoft is the world’s largest software company, its decisions regarding licensing and its integration of AI into its productivity tools have far-reaching consequences,” NetChoice stated in its criticism. “These practices not only harm competitors but also limit choice and innovation for consumers.”
Microsoft’s actions have also drawn the attention of international regulators. In September, Google lodged a formal complaint with the European Commission, accusing Microsoft of inflating the cost of running Windows Server on rival cloud platforms by as much as 400%. Google also cited instances where Microsoft was allegedly withholding timely and comprehensive security updates from customers using non-Microsoft cloud services.
The FTC’s investigation into Microsoft is part of a broader effort by U.S. regulators to scrutinize the market power of major technology companies. Microsoft has been somewhat of an exception to the ongoing crackdown on Big Tech, with companies like Facebook, Amazon, and Apple facing antitrust scrutiny in recent years. Google is also embroiled in two major lawsuits, including one where a judge found that the search giant unlawfully thwarted competition in the online search market.
Microsoft’s CEO, Satya Nadella, recently testified at a Google trial, accusing the company of using exclusive deals with content publishers to hinder competition in the artificial intelligence sector. This testimony highlights the increasing scrutiny of Big Tech’s dominance in AI, a field that is rapidly becoming central to the future of the digital economy.
The future of the Microsoft investigation could be influenced by shifting political dynamics in Washington. With the potential return of Donald Trump to the White House, there are questions about whether his administration would take a less aggressive stance on Big Tech regulation. While the Trump administration was known for its antitrust actions against tech giants, including its legal challenges to Google and Facebook, the incoming administration may alter the enforcement priorities of the FTC.
“Changes in administration can lead to evolving enforcement priorities,” noted Andre Barlow, an attorney with Doyle Barlow & Mazard. “It’s not unusual for investigations to continue across administrations, but the approach and level of scrutiny may change depending on who is in charge.”
Despite the potential shift in regulatory tone, Microsoft has historically benefited from certain policies under the Trump administration. In 2019, the Pentagon awarded Microsoft a $10 billion cloud computing contract, which Amazon had anticipated winning. Amazon later accused Trump of exerting undue influence to sway the contract away from Amazon Web Services (AWS), marking a controversial moment in the relationship between the tech giant and the U.S. government.
As the FTC’s investigation into Microsoft unfolds, industry observers will be closely watching how it impacts the company’s cloud computing and software practices. While Microsoft declined to comment on the investigation, its competitors and industry watchdogs are eager to see if the inquiry will lead to regulatory changes that could reshape the competitive landscape in both the cloud and AI markets. The ultimate outcome of this investigation, especially with the possibility of a new regulatory approach under a future administration, remains uncertain.
Read more: